We compared the top handyman services operating in Greenwood and south Indianapolis — on reviews, licensing, pricing, and accountability. Here's what we found.
Nick Studebaker has operated NHS from Greenwood since 2005 — making it one of the longest-tenured independent handymen in Johnson County. Unlike franchise services, you deal directly with the owner on every job. No subcontractors, no dispatch fees, no $90 inspection charge before work starts. NHS handles everything from drywall and TV mounting to bathroom tile, fixture replacement, and general home maintenance.
Get a Free Estimate →How the major Greenwood-area handyman services stack up across the factors that matter most to homeowners.
| Factor | NHS ★ | ACE Handyman Greenwood |
Handyman Connection Carmel |
Happy Handyman Indy |
Gig Apps Angi/Thumbtack |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Rating | 4.9★ / 81 reviews | ~4.5★ (est.) | ~4.5★ (est.) | Not confirmed | Varies by worker |
| BBB Accredited | A+ Accredited ✓ | A+ (franchise) | A+ (franchise) | Unknown | N/A |
| Owner-Operated | Yes — owner on job | Franchise (employees) | Franchise (employees) | Likely owner | No accountability |
| Licensed & Insured | Yes ✓ | Yes ✓ | Yes ✓ | Unknown | Varies — ask! |
| Estimate Fee | Free | Unknown | $90 fee | Free | Free (quote-based) |
| Min. Charge | ~$150 | Higher (franchise) | Higher (franchise) | ~$150 | Varies |
| Work Guarantee | Yes — 100% satisfaction | Franchise guarantee | Franchise guarantee | Unknown | Platform-dependent |
| Coverage Area | 19 cities (south Indy + suburbs) | Greenwood only | Carmel + north suburbs | Indianapolis area | All areas |
| Years in Market | 21+ years | Franchise (varies) | 25+ (franchise) | 30+ years | Unknown / new |
ACE Handyman Services is the home-improvement division of the ACE Hardware brand, with a franchise location directly serving Greenwood. They offer professional project management and carry the ACE Hardware name recognition. Pricing is higher than owner-operators due to franchise overhead. Coverage is limited to Greenwood territory — they don't cover the broader south Indianapolis suburbs that NHS serves.
Handyman Connection is a national franchise with a Carmel location that covers north Indianapolis suburbs. Their process involves a $90 inspection fee before work starts (credited against the job if you hire them). Carmel, Fishers, and Noblesville are their home territory. For Greenwood homeowners, travel time and the inspection fee add friction compared to hiring a local Greenwood-based service.
Happy Handyman is an independent owner-operator based in Indianapolis with 30+ years of experience — slightly longer than NHS's 21+ years. They offer free estimates and have established brand recognition in the city. Their web presence is limited compared to NHS (minimal service-specific pages, no confirmed BBB accreditation), and their coverage area appears to be more Indianapolis-centric than south-suburb focused.
Platforms like Angi and Thumbtack connect homeowners with independent workers and small contractors. Quality varies enormously — from legitimate tradespeople to unlicensed gig workers. Pricing can be lower, but so is accountability: there's no guarantee the person showing up is licensed, insured, or experienced.
| Situation | Best Choice |
|---|---|
| Greenwood homeowner, general repairs, wants owner accountability | Nick's Handyman Service, LLC (NHS) |
| Need Bargersville, Mooresville, Franklin, or Trafalgar | NHS (only service covering all of south Indy) |
Ratings and reviews: Google Business Profiles accessed May 2026. BBB accreditation status: Better Business Bureau (bbb.org), May 2026. Competitor pricing: publicly listed rates on competitor websites and HomeAdvisor market pricing guides (May 2026). Handyman Connection estimate fee: stated on handymanconnection.com/carmel. Coverage areas: verified from each company's published service area pages. Franchise designations: based on company self-description and national brand affiliation. Indiana licensing: Indiana Professional Licensing Agency (pla.IN.gov).
This comparison was last reviewed May 3, 2026. Pricing and ratings change — verify current information directly with each service before hiring.
Call or text Nick directly for a free estimate. No inspection fees, no middleman — just honest work from a 20-year Greenwood veteran.
(317) 893-3717 — Call or Text NickOr fill out our contact form for a callback • BBB A+ • 4.9★ Google • Licensed & Insured