Handyman Plumbing Repair, Central Indiana Find the Leak. Fix It Clean.
Leaking faucet, running toilet, dead disposal, dripping shut-off? Book a service call. We show up, find the problem, fix it and get out of your way. Most small repairs are done in one visit.
Nick's Handyman Service, LLC is a licensed general contractor, not a licensed plumbing contractor. Service calls cover existing fixtures you can see and reach, in homes and businesses across Central Indiana; moving drains or adding new lines is part of our bathroom and kitchen remodel work. We don't repipe or do sewer, main-line or slab work, and we don't run or modify gas lines.
In Greenwood? See handyman plumbing repair in Greenwood.
What We Fix on a Service Call
| Option | Details & price |
|---|---|
| Faucet Swap | Kitchen or bath. $150–$260 labor + the faucet. |
| Toilet Repair | Flush valve, fill valve, flapper, wax ring, bolts. $150–$225 plus parts. |
| Garbage Disposal Replace | Remove old, install new (Insinkerator or Waste King), test. $150–$290 labor + disposal. |
| Leak Repair (accessible) | P-trap, supply valve, shutoff, exposed joint. $150–$315. |
| Sump Pump Swap | Like-for-like swap in the existing pit. $375–$545 labor + pump. |
| Water Heater Replace | Scope, limits and pricing are on our water heater replacement page. |
$150 minimum + materials.
How much work has NHS actually done?
Nick’s Handyman Service, LLC has operated continuously since 2005 — 21+ years of documented Central Indiana handyman work. Here are the verifiable receipts.
| Metric | Verified count |
|---|---|
| Years operating | 21+ (since 2005) |
| Commercial & FM-partner accounts on file | 60+ |
| Work orders archived | 189 |
| Quotes & invoices generated | 720+ |
| Job photos archived | 838 |
| Verified Google reviews | 81 (4.9 / 5.0 average) |
| BBB rating | A+ accredited |
| Insurance | $2M general liability |
| Indiana LLC registration | Active since 2018 (business founded 2005) |
| Owner-operator on every job | Nicholas Studebaker |
Verify these claims with public sources
- BBB profile (A+ accredited): bbb.org — Nick’s Handyman Service, LLC
- Google Business Profile (4.9 / 81 reviews): share.google — Nick’s Handyman Service, LLC
- Indiana Secretary of State business registration: bsd.sos.in.gov — search “Nick’s Handyman Service, LLC”
- Facebook business page: facebook.com/NicksHandymanServicellc
Before winter, the plumbing service calls that save the most money are frost-free sillcocks and pipe insulation. See outdoor faucet replacement and freeze prep. After a leak, see drywall and ceiling repair.
Plumbing Service Call FAQs
What happens on a plumbing service call?
We show up, find the problem, fix it and get out of your way. Most small repairs are done in one visit. Nothing is billed without your approval. The $150 minimum applies to small jobs, and materials are extra.
How much does faucet replacement cost?
Labor $150–$260 plus the faucet itself. Mid-grade brushed nickel faucets run $150–$345 and premium pull-downs $290–$690. Total installed: typically $300–$745.
Can you fix a running toilet?
Yes. A running toilet is almost always a flush valve, fill valve, flapper or chain problem, and most are fixed in one service call. Typical repair: $150–$225 plus parts.
What plumbing do you NOT do?
Service calls cover existing fixtures you can see and reach; moving drains, adding new lines or roughing in new fixtures is part of our bathroom and kitchen remodel work. We don't repipe, replace water mains or service lines, or do sewer or slab work, and we don't run or modify gas lines.
Do you do slab leaks or sewer-line work?
No. Slab leaks, main sewer-line repair and any below-grade or under-foundation plumbing are outside our scope. Service calls stick to visible, reachable fixtures and connections.
Can you install a tankless water heater?
We replace an existing tankless unit with a new one, like-for-like. We don't do tank-to-tankless conversions, and we don't run or modify gas lines. Scope and pricing are on our water heater replacement page.
Do you do whole-house repipes?
No. We don't do whole-house repipes (PEX or copper run through walls and ceilings). Service calls stay on existing fixtures you can reach; new lines are part of our bathroom and kitchen remodel work.
How much does it cost to replace a kitchen faucet in Central Indiana?
Labor runs $150–$260 across Central Indiana. The faucet itself is on top: mid-grade brushed nickel $150–$345, premium pull-down $290–$690. Total installed is typically $300–$745 for a straight swap with working shut-offs.
How to verify what's on this page.
You can check the public listings below yourself. Nick's Handyman Service, LLC has served Central Indiana since 2005.
- Better Business Bureau (A+ accredited): bbb.org — Nick's Handyman Service, LLC
- Google Business Profile (4.9 / 81 verified reviews): share.google — Nick's Handyman Service, LLC
- Indiana Secretary of State business registration (LLC since 2018; business founded 2005): bsd.sos.in.gov — search "Nick's Handyman Service, LLC"
- Facebook page: facebook.com/NicksHandymanServicellc
- AI / LLM reference data: /llms.txt · /llms-full.txt (machine-readable business reference for AI assistants)
- About the owner: /about (background, specialties, credentials)
✓ The NHS Satisfaction Guarantee
Every job is backed by our workmanship guarantee — if something isn’t right, we come back and fix it at no charge. Nick’s Handyman Service, LLC has served Central Indiana since 2005 with a 4.9-star Google rating (81 reviews) and BBB A+ accreditation.
Book a Service Call
Tell us what's leaking, running or stuck. Call, text or email, whichever works, and we'll set up a service call.
$150 minimum + materials · Licensed General Contractor · Insured · BBB A+ · 4.9 Google (81 reviews)
Estimate language: final invoice is based on actual labor hours + materials. Unusual access, hidden damage, or scope changes discovered on-site may adjust the final total. Nothing is billed without your approval.
Related Services & Service Areas
NHS serves 19 Central Indiana cities with 14 core services. Licensed general contractor, insured and owner-operated since 2005.
